The Marriage Bed by Laura Lee Guhrke
Note: This is from myspace blog dated 11/25/05. I thought I'd put it over here.
Isabel Says:
All right. If that was me and my husband and Joey said "Look baby, I need a son, so you and me are getting it on" I would say F*ck you asshole. I mean, Viola put up with 8 years of watching John having affairs. She couldn't divorce him cause this was back in the day when you couldn't. John starts courting his wife, hoping she'll forgive him and fall in love with him. However, she can't get over his affairs. John tell Viola thatbecausee she turned him away, he could only go so long before turning to another woman. He only had the affairs cause he was lonely and trying to forget Viola. Excuse me while I gag.
So, I didn't care for this book. The only thing that kept me reading was that I was curious to find out what Viola would do. Yeah, no reread for this one.
Grade: D, only because the book did keep me interested.
Holly says:
I have to disagree with you. I loved The Marriage Bed. Although the whole "You have to give me an heir" thing irked, I wasn't totally turned off by it. I read the first two books, Guilty Pleasures and His Every Kiss first, and to be honest, I hated John by the time I was finished with those two. After the way he treated Viola, I didn't think he could be redeemed.
But I was wrong.
He certainly wasn't my most favorite hero, but I liked that she didn't just cave in to him and give him what he wanted. And that scene where he's standing in the rain nearly broke my heart.
I'm not excusing his past behaviors, but I think Laura Lee Guhrke did an amazing job of turning him around for me. It wasn't one of the best books I've ever read, but it wasn't too bad.
I give it 3.5 out of 5
Jazz says:
Okay I read the first two books in this trilogy and loved them soo soo much. In those books you meet the Heroine from this book, Viola. You fall in love with the heart broken woman who at a very young age married a man she loved and who betrayed her and has been having continual affairs. You never meet John outright but hear about all the horrible things he does. So by time I started reading TMB I was ready to hate him. Well let me tell you LLG did aawesomee job at making you fall in love with a man that was so wrong in everything he did. The reason I gave this book a C was not because of the writing, which was top of the line, or the lack of interest in the story cause I was so into it. But because I personally could not imagine making any of the decisions the heroine did.
After John had had affairsamongg many women of the ton for 9 years he decides to come back to Viola because he finally needs an heir. He basically tells her the reason he went to all of those women was because she turned him out of her bed and was so unforgiving. Well she turned him out of her bed because she felt betrayed when she found out he had lied to her and was keeping a mistress while they were courting. Then instead ofapologizingg or begging for her understanding and explaining he gives her a month to 'get over it' and come back to him and when she doesn't he just leaves. Then starts the 9 years of affairs. During that time Viola is forced by her social standing to suffer through dinners, card games, balls and more with the women her husband is sleeping with.
Now LLG did a very good job of redeeming John...how heart broken he was when his sister died when he was just a child, how his parents never showed him any love, how his best friend and cousin died. But still can all theunhappinesss he suffered through be excuse enough for all he did? Not to say in the nine years they were married he didn't change but did thatcancele out all the horribly wrong things he did to his marriage? I just don't know.
One other thing that John did that really rubbed me the wrong way was when Viola, after taking a huge chance on loving himagainn, asked if he would promise to stay faithful he wouldn't promise. He said it depended on her! Well if he really loved her, as he supposedly did at the end, no matter what she did he would have stayed faithful. Right?
But like I said in thebeginningg I did end up falling for John, and I loved Viola from the start. But honestly I don't know if I could have made the hard choices Viola did. I give hera lott of props as a great heroine, it would take a very strong woman to forgive like she did.
Grade: C
Labels: Historicals, Holly's Reviews, Isabel's Reviews, Jazz's Reviews, Laura Lee Guhrke
---------------------------------------------
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home